Newcastle get ‘justice’ after ‘ridiculous’ VAR penalty decision against PSG

January 29, 2026 - 02:53

A moment of immense controversy has overshadowed the closing stages of Newcastle United's valiant Champions League clash with Paris Saint-Germain. The Magpies, having defended superbly to protect a narrow lead into stoppage time, were left stunned when a VAR review awarded the French champions a late penalty.

The incident occurred when a cross from PSG's Ousmane Dembélé struck the chest of young midfielder Lewis Miley before appearing to brush his lower arm, which was tucked tightly against his body. Despite minimal contact and a seemingly natural position, referee Szymon Marciniak was sent to the pitchside monitor and subsequently pointed to the spot. Kylian Mbappé converted the resulting penalty in the 98th minute, snatching a dramatic draw for the home side.

The decision has been met with widespread disbelief and anger. Pundits and fans alike have labeled the call "ridiculous" and "harsh," arguing it goes against the spirit of the handball rule which is intended to punish deliberate action. Newcastle's players and staff were visibly distraught at the final whistle, feeling a famous victory was unjustly taken from their grasp. The contentious moment has ignited a fresh debate over the consistency and application of VAR in football's biggest competitions, leaving Newcastle's hopes of progression hanging by a thread after a bitter evening in Paris.